Two investors can earn exactly the same average return over exactly the same period and still end up with very different amounts of money. The difference comes from the order in which the good and bad years arrive. This is called sequence-of-returns risk, and it matters most at one point in life: when you start withdrawing money from your portfolio.
A real example: retiring in January 2000
Imagine retiring at the start of 2000 with $1,000,000 invested in the S&P 500, with dividends reinvested. Each January you withdraw a fixed $50,000 to live on, and the rest stays invested.
These are the actual January-to-January total returns of the S&P 500 that you would have experienced (calculated from Shiller's monthly data):
| Year | Return | Year | Return | Year | Return |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2000 | −5.2% | 2008 | −35.6% | 2016 | 21.1% |
| 2001 | −13.5% | 2009 | 33.3% | 2017 | 25.0% |
| 2002 | −20.1% | 2010 | 16.4% | 2018 | −4.7% |
| 2003 | 28.6% | 2011 | 3.4% | 2019 | 28.2% |
| 2004 | 6.1% | 2012 | 16.2% | 2020 | 17.9% |
| 2005 | 10.1% | 2013 | 25.6% | 2021 | 22.2% |
| 2006 | 13.4% | 2014 | 13.5% | 2022 | −12.0% |
| 2007 | −1.4% | 2015 | −3.4% |
Over those 23 years the average annual return was 8.0%, and the compound (geometric) return was 6.5% a year.
Now run the same 23 returns through twice — once in their real order, and once in reverse, so the strong years of the 2010s come first and the 2000–02 crash comes last:
| After | Real order (2000 → 2022) | Reversed order |
|---|---|---|
| 3 years | $547,845 | $1,073,155 |
| 5 years | $625,915 | $1,201,296 |
| 10 years | $408,467 | $2,112,545 |
| 15 years | $418,239 | $2,298,191 |
| 20 years | $363,251 | $3,482,027 |
| 23 years | $299,278 | $2,159,898 |
Same returns. Same average. Same withdrawals. One retiree is left with less than a third of their starting capital; the other has more than doubled it.
Why the order matters
Without withdrawals, order does not matter at all. Multiplication is commutative: 1.10 × 0.80 gives the same result as 0.80 × 1.10. If you invested $1,000,000 in 2000 and withdrew nothing, you would have ended 2022 with about 4.25 times your money whichever way round the years came.
Withdrawals break this symmetry. When you take $50,000 out after a bad year, you are selling at low prices, and those shares are no longer there to benefit from the recovery. In the real-order example, the retiree withdrew $150,000 during 2000–02 while the portfolio was also falling about 35%. By the time the market recovered, the portfolio was too small to recover with it — and then 2008 hit.
In the reversed order, the early strong years built a large cushion. When the bad years finally arrived, the withdrawals were a small fraction of a much bigger portfolio.
It is not always this dramatic
Sequence risk depends on when the bad years cluster. Run the same experiment for 1990–2019 — a period whose worst years fell in the middle — and the two orders end close together: about $9.5 million in real order against about $9.0 million reversed. The early years of retirement are the danger zone. Losses in the first five to ten years do far more damage than the same losses later.
The mirror image: sequence risk while saving
While you are still adding money, the effect runs the other way. A crash early in your saving years lets your regular contributions buy shares cheaply, and a crash just before you stop working hurts the most because your balance is at its largest. That is why the years just before and just after retirement — sometimes called the "retirement red zone" — deserve the most care.
Ways to manage sequence risk
- Keep a cash or short-term bond buffer. One to three years of withdrawals held outside of stocks means you are not forced to sell shares during a crash.
- Be flexible with withdrawals. Spending a little less after a bad year, and resuming afterwards, can greatly improve how long a portfolio lasts.
- Start with a sustainable withdrawal rate. The example above withdraws 5% of the starting value every year, which is aggressive. Lower initial rates leave much more room for a bad start.
- Plan for a range, not a single number. A single projected line hides sequence risk entirely. Our calculator runs 1,000 simulated return sequences and shows the 10th to 90th percentile range so you can see how wide the outcomes can be.
Notes on the example
Returns are January-to-January total returns of the S&P 500 calculated from Robert Shiller's monthly dataset (monthly average prices, dividends reinvested), so they differ slightly from calendar-year figures published elsewhere. Withdrawals are a fixed $50,000 taken at the start of each year and are not adjusted for inflation. Taxes and fees are ignored. Data: Shiller, U.S. Stock Markets 1871–Present via datasets/s-and-p-500.
This guide is educational and not investment advice. Past performance does not guarantee future results.