When people quote how much the stock market has "gone up", they usually mean the index level — the S&P 500 number on the news. But the index level leaves out dividends, the cash that companies pay to shareholders. Over long periods, reinvested dividends have made an enormous difference to what investors actually earned.

This guide measures that difference using Robert Shiller's S&P 500 data from 1871 to mid-2023, and looks at how it has changed over time.

Price return vs total return

  • Price return is the change in the index level only.
  • Total return assumes every dividend is reinvested back into the index, so dividends buy more shares, which then earn their own dividends.

The gap between the two is the contribution of dividends.

Period Price return a year Total return a year Difference from dividends Dividends' share of compound growth Average dividend yield
1871 – mid-2023 4.62% 9.17% 4.55 points 48.5% 4.27%
1926 – mid-2023 6.18% 10.16% 3.98 points 38.1% 3.69%
1950 – mid-2023 7.85% 11.28% 3.43 points 29.2% 3.13%
1980 – mid-2023 8.82% 11.59% 2.77 points 23.0% 2.52%
2000 – mid-2023 4.87% 6.83% 1.96 points 28.0% 1.85%

Over the full 152 years, dividends were responsible for roughly half of the stock market's compound growth. The share is smaller over more recent periods, for reasons covered below — but even since 1980, dividends added almost three percentage points a year.

What that means in dollars

Small annual differences compound into very large gaps:

$10,000 invested in… Value in mid-2023, price only Value in mid-2023, dividends reinvested
January 1950 about $2.57 million about $25.5 million
January 1980 about $392,000 about $1.17 million
January 2000 about $30,500 about $47,000

Since 1950, reinvesting dividends turned the same starting amount into roughly ten times as much money as the price gains alone.

After inflation, dividends matter even more

From 1871 to mid-2023, the index level rose just 2.45% a year after inflation. With dividends reinvested, the real return was 6.90% a year. In real terms, most of what investors gained over the long run came from dividends, not from rising prices.

This also explains why some historical bear markets were less damaging than the index suggests. After the 1929 crash, the price index took until 1954 to regain its peak, but with dividends reinvested and adjusted for the deflation of the 1930s, investors' real wealth had recovered by late 1936. See every S&P 500 bear market since 1871 for both versions side by side.

Decade by decade

Decade Price return a year Total return a year Difference from dividends Average dividend yield
1880s 0.52% 5.71% 5.19 points 5.04%
1890s 1.26% 5.70% 4.44 points 4.30%
1900s 5.15% 9.90% 4.75 points 4.42%
1910s −1.32% 4.66% 5.98 points 5.89%
1920s 9.41% 15.49% 6.08 points 5.42%
1930s −5.52% −0.17% 5.35 points 5.52%
1940s 3.22% 9.23% 6.01 points 5.67%
1950s 13.14% 18.76% 5.62 points 4.87%
1960s 4.52% 7.87% 3.35 points 3.16%
1970s 2.08% 6.25% 4.17 points 4.01%
1980s 11.85% 16.63% 4.78 points 4.19%
1990s 15.41% 18.24% 2.83 points 2.43%
2000s −2.35% −0.58% 1.77 points 1.80%
2010s 11.30% 13.53% 2.23 points 1.98%

Decades run from January to January. Three patterns stand out:

  • In weak decades, dividends were most of the return. In the 1880s, 1890s, 1910s and 1970s, prices barely moved or fell, and dividends supplied most or all of the gain. In the 1930s, they turned a 5.5%-a-year price decline into a roughly flat result.
  • In strong decades, prices dominated. In the 1950s, 1980s, 1990s and 2010s, rising prices did most of the work, though dividends still added two to six points a year.
  • The contribution has shrunk. Before 1950, dividends added five to six points a year in most decades. Since 1990, it has been about two to three.

Why dividend yields have fallen

The dividend yield is the annual dividend divided by the price. In this data, the median yield was 5.1% from 1871 to 1949, 3.7% from 1950 to 1989, and 1.9% from 1990 to mid-2023. It hit a high of 13.8% in June 1932, when prices had collapsed, and a low of 1.1% in August 2000, at the peak of the dot-com bubble. In June 2023 it was 1.6%.

Two things explain most of the decline:

  1. Higher valuations. When prices rise faster than dividends, the yield falls. Periods of very high prices relative to earnings — such as 2000 — produced the lowest yields. See how valuations relate to future returns.
  2. Share buybacks. Since the 1980s, US companies have returned a growing share of their cash to shareholders by buying back their own shares rather than paying dividends. Buybacks show up in the price return instead of the dividend column, so part of the shift is a change in how companies pay shareholders rather than a fall in how much they pay.

Practical takeaways

  1. Compare like with like. When you see a long-term return figure, check whether it includes dividends. A 7% price return and a 9% total return can describe the same market.
  2. Reinvest unless you need the income. Automatically reinvesting dividends is how the total-return figures above were achieved. Accumulating ("Acc") fund share classes do this for you.
  3. Use total-return assumptions for planning. The return presets in our calculator are total-return assumptions. If you plan to spend your dividends instead, use a lower return.
  4. Think in real terms. After inflation, dividends have been the larger part of long-run stock returns — see real vs nominal returns.

Notes

Data: Robert J. Shiller, U.S. Stock Markets 1871–Present, via datasets/s-and-p-500, through June 2023. Prices are monthly averages of daily closes; dividends are Shiller's annualised index dividends, reinvested monthly; inflation uses Shiller's CPI series. "Dividends' share of compound growth" compares the logarithms of the price and total-return growth rates; it is not meaningful for decades with negative returns. Taxes on dividends and fund fees are ignored, so investors' actual results would have been lower. Calculations are our own.

This guide is educational and not investment advice. Past performance does not guarantee future results.