Leverage — investing with borrowed money, or through leveraged ETFs — looks simple on paper. If the market returns 9% a year, a 2× position should return 18%. In practice, it almost never works out that way. Two forces get in the way: volatility drag and the cost of borrowing. And leverage makes drawdowns so deep that many investors are forced out before the long-run maths can work.
Volatility drag in one example
Suppose an index rises 10% one day and falls 9.09% the next. It ends exactly where it started:
100 × 1.10 × (1 − 0.0909) = 100
Now look at a fund that resets to 2× the index every day. It rises 20%, then falls 18.18%:
100 × 1.20 × (1 − 0.1818) = 98.18
The index is flat, but the 2× fund has lost 1.8%. A 3× fund would rise 30% and fall 27.27%, ending at 94.55 — down 5.5%. Repeat that back-and-forth and leveraged funds steadily lose value even when the market goes nowhere.
The reason is the same asymmetry that drives drawdown recovery: a percentage loss has to be followed by a larger percentage gain to recover, and leverage makes the losses larger.
The rule of thumb
For an investment with average (arithmetic) annual return a and volatility σ, the long-run compound growth rate is roughly:
compound growth ≈ a − σ² / 2
The σ²/2 term is the volatility drag. Leverage of L multiplies the average return by L but multiplies the drag by L² — and you also pay interest on the borrowed part. Using our calculator's "Aggressive" assumptions (9% average return, 17% volatility) and a 5% borrowing cost:
| Leverage | Average return | Volatility | Approx. compound growth after borrowing costs |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1× | 9% | 17% | about 7.6% |
| 2× | 18% | 34% | about 7.2% |
| 3× | 27% | 51% | about 4.0% |
Under these assumptions, doubling the risk produces no extra long-run growth, and tripling it produces less. The exact numbers depend on the assumptions, but the shape — rapidly diminishing, then negative, returns to extra leverage — is general.
What history says
To test this against real data, we simulated portfolios holding 1×, 2× and 3× the S&P 500 (with dividends), rebalanced to the target leverage every month, paying interest on the borrowed amount equal to the 10-year Treasury yield. The results:
| Period | 1× | 2× | 3× |
|---|---|---|---|
| Aug 1929 – Jun 1932: total change | −81% | −98% | −99.9% |
| Oct 2007 – Mar 2009: total change | −49% | −78% | −92% |
| Jan 2000 – Jun 2023: annual return | 6.8% | 8.4% | 7.2% |
| Jan 2000 – Jun 2023: worst drawdown | −49.0% | −80.7% | −95.4% |
| Jan 1950 – Jun 2023: annual return | 11.3% | 15.4% | 17.6% |
| Jan 1950 – Jun 2023: worst drawdown | −49.0% | −80.7% | −95.4% |
There is an honest case for leverage in this table: over the unusually strong 1950–2023 period, the simulated 2× and 3× portfolios compounded faster than the index. But look at what they had to survive to get there. A 2× investor saw their portfolio fall more than 80% at least once; a 3× investor saw it fall more than 95%. From 2000 onwards, 3× leverage earned only slightly more than holding the index, despite carrying several times the risk. And anyone who was 2× or 3× leveraged going into 1929 was all but wiped out.
Why the real-world results would probably be worse
This simulation is generous to leverage:
- Monthly data hides daily swings. It uses monthly average prices, which understate volatility. Real daily-reset leveraged ETFs experience the full daily volatility, and with it more drag.
- No margin calls. A real leveraged account that falls 80% would usually have been closed out by the broker long before the bottom, locking in the loss.
- No fees. Leveraged ETFs charge higher fees than index funds, and borrowing costs for individuals are typically above the Treasury yield.
- Perfect discipline. The simulation assumes the investor never sells in panic during an 80–95% loss. Very few people could.
Practical takeaways
- The biggest risk is not low returns — it is being forced out. Leverage can work over a long period only if you can survive the drawdowns without selling or being margin-called.
- Volatility matters more as leverage rises. On a volatile asset, even modest leverage can reduce long-run growth.
- Leveraged ETFs are designed for short-term trading. Their daily reset makes long-term results depend heavily on the path of the market, not just where it ends up.
- Test it before you do it. Move the leverage slider in our calculator and watch the 10th-percentile outcome. It falls much faster than the expected path rises. Then check how big a gain you would need to recover from a leveraged drawdown with the drawdown recovery calculator.
Notes
Simulation data: Robert J. Shiller, U.S. Stock Markets 1871–Present, via datasets/s-and-p-500. Monthly total returns, rebalanced monthly to constant leverage; borrowing cost is the 10-year Treasury yield, used as a rough proxy. Approximation table uses a·L − (σL)²/2 − (L−1)·5%. Calculations are our own.
This guide is educational and not investment advice. Leveraged products can lose most or all of their value.